It’s a wonderful message we can take to current times.įurthermore, it also adds a lot more meaning to current times, as we deal with the COVID crisis, disagreements with those you love, and some other things as well – which shine a new light on our personal lives not going as we had hoped or expected. While it’s certainly different in the movies, I believe they’ve paraphrased Sam’s speech very powerfully. It mentions all the stuff that happened in the First and Second Ages, as well as part of the Third Age – Beren and Luthien, Bilbo’s Journey, etc. I also think that for a speech this powerful, the book adds so much richness to it – especially as Frodo and Sam didn’t know what was going to happen. It sometimes just gives us a sense that someone is talking to us in that way, especially when we feel isolated and alone like the only ones in the situation we’re in right now. When things aren’t going as we expected, there are definitely a lot of things we can turn to from here. Usually, it’s the message I’d turn to during tough times. As it does provide for more of a conversational tone in it. But I disagree – there is still at least an element of Sam’s speech in the books, which I think it seems more like a dialogue.īut for the sake of this post, I’ll focus on the book adaptations of Sam’s Speech – in which you could say it’s a dialogue. Some may say that Sam’s speech was a feature added onto the movies that wasn’t in the books. I know it sounds a bit nitpicky for such a great quote though. While the quote above was in the movies, it is unknown whether it was in the books. I cited the movies as I initially thought the above quote was exclusive to the movies. Peter Jackson, The Two Towers Movie Adaptations When I watched Sam’s speech the first few times, I didn’t skip to the end but noticed it a lot – where he said: Though I do understand why they had to paraphrase it to an extent.īut it has the same message. It adds so much richness to it that the movie paraphrases. Many thought otherwise – you’ll see TONS of posts out there saying that this eye-opening speech was added in the movies, but not in the books.īut I beg to differ – there is a book equivalent as well. One of them provided an interesting take, in that this speech was redone in the movies, which I completely overlooked. The first time I heard about it was when I went back to school (the first one as a huge fan of the series) and was so glad to see a couple of students talking about it as well. I was thinking about it for a while, but couldn’t help but feel that the difference between Sam’s speech in the books and movies stuck out to me like a sore thumb. There’s one part which never ceases to move me, and many of us – it’s Sam’s Speech, regardless of whether it’s from the book or movie. But you’ve left out one of the chief characters…. And why sir, I’ve never thought about it before!.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |